Restaurant Award
Home Rankings Praise Awards Trending Methodology
search

Navigation

Restaurant rankings, praise awards, monthly trending, and our methodology.

Home / Rankings / Praise Awards / Trending / Methodology / Owner login /
  1. home Home
  2. › Trending
  3. › Florida
  4. › Key West
  5. › Italian Restaurants

Trending Italian Restaurants in Key West, Florida

Monthly discoveries · Places on the rise

Good places keep getting better. Discover italian restaurants making the biggest gains in Restaurant Score and find a new favourite for your next visit.

calendar_monthScores as of October 30, 2026

The Restaurants on the rise

Leading monthly increases · Key West
Illustrative image: Destination dining room
81.1
#1

Key West Florida

New York Pasta Garden

trending_up+4.2pts
View Restaurant arrow_forward
Illustrative image: Close-up of a bright coastal restaurant dish
81.0
#2

Key West Florida

Mangia Mangia

trending_up+3.8pts
View Restaurant arrow_forward
Illustrative image: Moody restaurant interior with polished service
71.8
#3

Key West Florida

La Trattoria Oceanside

trending_up+0.7pts
View Restaurant arrow_forward

More restaurants gaining ground

Illustrative image: Chef-led tasting counter framed in warm wood
#4

Abbondanza Italian Restaurant

place Key West, Florida

trending_up+0.4pts
77.2
View Restaurant arrow_forward

Progress you can see.

A little context

Trending follows the largest positive changes in Restaurant Score over a monthly comparison. The current scores are dated October 30, 2026; the comparison target is September 30, 2026. The nearest earlier weekly observation, up to 14 days before that target, supplies each restaurant's starting score.

Changes are measured in points. This list reflects score growth; our restaurant rankings in Key West offer another way to discover places by their current score. Explore the scoring methodology for more context.

Follow your appetite.

More monthly discoveries

Trending American restaurant in Key West

Explore Trendingarrow_forward

Trending Bar & grill in Key West

Explore Trendingarrow_forward

Trending Barbecue restaurant in Key West

Explore Trendingarrow_forward
More cities in Florida
location_onAlachualocation_onAlafayalocation_onAlfordlocation_onAltamonte Springslocation_onApollo Beachlocation_onAtlantic Beachlocation_onAventuralocation_onBay Lakelocation_onBayonet Pointlocation_onBee Ridgelocation_onBellair-Meadowbrook Terracelocation_onBelleviewlocation_onBoca Ratonlocation_onBonita Springslocation_onBoynton Beachlocation_onBradentonlocation_onBradfordvillelocation_onBrandon
Restaurant Award Independent restaurant intelligence

Where exceptional restaurants
earn their place.

United States

Evidence-led rankings that turn public signals into meaningful recognition.

Explore the rankings arrow_forward Learn About Our Methodology arrow_forward
Discover
  • Rankings
  • Praise Awards
  • Trending
  • Methodology
  • Home
Information
  • For restaurant owners
  • Support
  • Frequently asked
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

© 2026 Restaurant Award. All rights reserved.

Data-led. Independently ranked.

Help us improve your RestaurantAward experience by allowing optional cookies. Privacy policy

Could not save your preference. Please try again.