Best Italian Restaurants in Key West, Florida

Find the best Italian restaurants in Key West, Florida, with an Italian meal with time for the company around the table in mind. From a simple pasta craving to a longer dinner, use current menus to choose the style of Italian meal you want. Make the choice local: decide where in Key West you want to spend time, who is joining you, and how much of the day you want to give to enjoying the meal together. The current Key West guide includes New York Pasta Garden and Mangia Mangia, giving you specific places to explore before making plans.

Think about whether the outing calls for familiar comfort or a kitchen you are curious to get to know. Restaurant Score helps compare public dining signals, while the profiles bring the individual Key West kitchens into focus. Give the same search a wider view through Italian Restaurants in Florida and Italian Restaurants across the United States. Keep the Key West visit personal by checking the details that matter to your company and your plans.