Live venue positions in New York are temporarily unavailable.
Best Pizza Restaurants in New York
More Places
#51
Tazza Pizza
Syracuse, New York
2
81.5
#52
Sal's Pizzeria
Ithaca, New York
0
81.4
#53
One Pie Pizza Co
West Seneca, New York
8
81.4
#54
Al Dente Pizzeria
Rye, New York
6
81.3
#55
Hudson & Packard
Poughkeepsie, New York
12
81.3
#56
Village Pizzeria and Restaurant
Floral Park, New York
1
81.3
#57
Pizzeria Posto Rhinebeck
Rhinebeck, New York
18
81.1
#58
La Pizza Roma🇮🇹
New York City, New York
0
81.1
#59
New York Pizzeria
Cato, New York
4
80.9
#60
Edie's Pizza & Subs
Hamburg, New York
4
80.9
#61
Atlas Brick Oven Pizzeria
Corning, New York
5
80.8
#62
Pudgie's Pizzeria
Rochester, New York
1
80.8
#63
Candyman Pizza / Caputi's Pub
Tonawanda Town, New York
8
80.8
#64
J-Joe kosher pizza & berrylicious
White Plains, New York
2
80.7
#65
Caputo's Pizza
Middletown, New York
1
80.7
#66
Apizza Regionale
Syracuse, New York
1
80.7
#67
Sardo's Pizzeria
Greenlawn, New York
9
80.6
#68
Stromboli's Restaurant
Rochester, New York
1
80.6
#69
Good Guys Pizza
North Tonawanda, New York
2
80.5
#70
Allegro Italian & Mexican Food
Baldwin, New York
1
80.5
#71
Brooklyn’s Finest Pizza
Cheektowaga, New York
17
80.5
#72
Misto
Floral Park, New York
13
80.5
#73
Victors Pizza and Pasta House
Melville, New York
4
80.4
#74
Silvio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Yonkers, New York
0
80.4
#75
Ciao
Lansing, New York
13
80.3