Live venue positions in New York are temporarily unavailable.
Best Pizza Restaurants in New York
More Places
#26
Gilda's Skaneateles
Skaneateles, New York
15
83.4
#27
Wise Guys Pizza Buffalo
Buffalo, New York
1
83.2
#28
Aniello's Pizzeria
Corning, New York
16
83.1
#29
Fire Stone Grill and Pizza
Franklin Square, New York
7
83.1
#30
GG's Pizza
East Rochester, New York
14
83.1
#31
Vinnie's Pizzeria
New York City, New York
1
83.0
#32
Bear Mountain Pizza & Cafe
Fort Montgomery, New York
12
82.7
#33
Pizza Fenice
Pelham, New York
19
82.5
#34
John's of Bleecker Street
New York City, New York
2
82.5
#35
Joey's Pizza Depew
Depew, New York
9
82.5
#36
La Hacienda Brighton
Tonawanda Town, New York
1
82.5
#37
New York Pizzeria
New Berlin, New York
3
82.3
#38
The Pizzeria of Smithtown
Village of the Branch, New York
21
82.1
#39
SIMÒ PIZZA - MEATPACKING
New York City, New York
1
82.1
#40
De Fazio's
Troy, New York
4
82.0
#41
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
Bay Shore, New York
4
81.9
#42
Turiello's Pizza House
Nyack, New York
7
81.9
#43
The Pizzeria of Babylon
Babylon, New York
9
81.9
#44
Bravo Pizza (K)
Great Neck Plaza, New York
3
81.8
#45
Mother Kellys
Rockville Centre, New York
1
81.8
#46
Stone’s Pizza Shop
Wappingers Falls, New York
16
81.8
#47
Prince Umberto
Franklin Square, New York
3
81.7
#48
Soho Pizza
Albany, New York
1
81.7
#49
Yummy's Pizza - Monsey
Monsey, New York
20
81.6
#50
A & V Pizzeria
Yonkers, New York
1
81.5