Live venue positions in New York are temporarily unavailable.
Best Italian Restaurants in New York
More Places
#51
Valentina's Ristorante
Mount Vernon, New York
7
82.4
#52
Augie's Family Style Italian Restaurant
Ballston Spa, New York
7
82.3
#53
Celeste
New York City, New York
0
82.3
#54
Canali's Italian & American Restaurant
Rotterdam, New York
9
82.3
#55
Mr. Dominic's at the Lake
Rochester, New York
0
82.2
#56
La Spezia
Sea Cliff, New York
10
82.1
#57
Pastaru Pastificio
Mineola, New York
3
82.1
#58
Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant White Plains
White Plains, New York
4
82.0
#59
Grotta di Fuoco
Long Beach, New York
2
82.0
#60
Trattoria DiMeo
Roslyn Heights, New York
14
82.0
#61
Mama's of Copiague
Copiague, New York
17
82.0
#62
Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails
Massapequa Park, New York
11
82.0
#63
388
Albertson, New York
10
82.0
#64
RIOS Modern Italian
Thornwood, New York
6
81.9
#65
Frankie’s 823
St. James, New York
8
81.9
#66
Zuppa
Yonkers, New York
3
81.9
#67
Pietro & Son
Elmira, New York
1
81.9
#68
Mima Vinoteca
Irvington, New York
2
81.8
#69
Bella Michael's Restaurant
Oneonta, New York
2
81.8
#70
Pete's Trattoria
Watertown, New York
7
81.6
#71
Carlo's
Yonkers, New York
0
81.6
#72
Filomena's Restaurant
Franklin Square, New York
9
81.6
#73
Piccolo Cucina e Vino
Middletown, New York
5
81.6
#74
Cafe Testarossa
Syosset, New York
4
81.6
#75
Fortuna’s Restaurant & Banquets
Niagara Falls, New York
1
81.6