Live venue positions in New York are temporarily unavailable.
Best Italian Restaurants in New York
More Places
#26
The Pasta Villa
Irondequoit, New York
2
83.8
#27
King Umberto
Elmont, New York
18
83.8
#28
Mambo Italiano
Irvington, New York
17
83.7
#29
Taverna Di Bacco
New York City, New York
2
83.5
#30
Toscana of Cooperstown
Cooperstown, New York
20
83.5
#31
179 BAR AND GRILL
New Rochelle, New York
7
83.3
#32
The Cookery
Dobbs Ferry, New York
7
83.3
#33
88 Charles St Restaurant
Montgomery, New York
6
83.2
#34
Lucano
Rochester, New York
1
83.2
#35
La Famiglia
Smithtown, New York
6
83.0
#36
Carmine's Italian Deli & Cafe
Elmsford, New York
13
83.0
#37
Antonino's Italian Restaurant
Manhasset, New York
1
82.9
#38
Basso by PXK
Chappaqua, New York
21
82.9
#39
Rocky's
Rochester, New York
1
82.9
#40
Serano's Italian
New York City, New York
2
82.8
#41
Christina's Restaurant
Lincoln Park, New York
8
82.8
#42
Park Side Restaurant
New York City, New York
2
82.7
#43
Torrey Park Restaurant
Geneva, New York
3
82.7
#44
Cornell's in Little Italy Restaurant
Schenectady, New York
1
82.7
#45
Giulio's Restaurant
Tappan, New York
9
82.6
#46
Il Fresco
Orangeburg, New York
17
82.6
#47
La Famiglia Pizzeria & Restaurant
Glen Cove, New York
5
82.6
#48
Isabelle's Osteria
New York City, New York
2
82.5
#49
Lombardo
Buffalo, New York
3
82.5
#50
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
Centereach, New York
3
82.5