Restaurant Award
Top 1 in Islamorada, Village of Islands Seafood restaurant

Island Grill

See how Island Grill ranks, what guests notice, and which signals shape its position in Islamorada, Village of Islands.

Claim This Restaurant For Free

For owners and authorised managers. Verify ownership to manage your venue.

82.0 Restaurant Award Score Out of 100
#1 Islamorada, Village of Islands rank of 8 Restaurants
1 / 12 Ranking awards Current / historical
3 / 40 Praise awards Current / historical

Restaurant Awards

Island Grill Restaurant

4 active awards and 52 historical awards on record. Earned awards remain active for 60 days from the award date, independently of the latest weekly ranking.

Selected main award · Bronze Award

Seafood

Islamorada, Village of Islands · City Ranking

Ranking
#3
Venues In This Field
8
Award date
Oct 2026

Your Awards. The Full Collection Awaits.

55 more

Current ranking awards

The complete current ranking record, including the selected main award.

1Current
  • Seafood restaurant Islamorada, Village of Islands

Historical ranking awards

Earlier distinctions, preserved in the award record.

12Historical
  1. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  2. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  3. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  4. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  5. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  6. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  7. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  8. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  9. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  10. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  11. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked
  12. Date locked Historical distinction Award details locked

Guest Praise awards

Earned for what guests praise most.

3Current
Current Guest Praise3
Historical Guest Praise40

Reveal every category, location and historical award in your complete award record.

Claim To Unlock All Awards

The ranking journey

A reputation,
written over time.

From a local address to a broader standing.
Explore Island Grill’s place in the city, state and national field.

RestaurantsCurrent ranking · Oct 2026
Oct 9, 2026
Islamorada, Village of Islands category rank#1 of 8
Award Score82 / 100
Islamorada, Village of Islands category rank and Restaurant Award Score Gold shows recorded category ranks on the left axis, with number one at the top. Mint overlays Restaurant Award Score on an independent right axis from 0 to 100. Lines connect recorded observations; missing values are not estimated. Comparison-field sizes and scoring methodology can change. Use the date slider or the data table below for exact values. Rank Score / 100 #1#2 0255075100 Feb 2026May 2026Jul 2026Oct 2026 Islamorada, Village of Islands category rank and Restaurant Award Score Gold shows recorded category ranks on the left axis, with number one at the top. Mint overlays Restaurant Award Score on an independent right axis from 0 to 100. Lines connect recorded observations; missing values are not estimated. Comparison-field sizes and scoring methodology can change. Use the date slider or the data table below for exact values. Rank Score / 100 #1#2 0255075100 Feb 2026Jun 2026Oct 2026
View recorded values
DateRankComparison fieldAward Score / 100
Feb 25, 2026#1889
Feb 26, 2026#1889
Mar 3, 2026#1883.5
Mar 6, 2026#1880.8
Mar 16, 2026#1880.8
Mar 20, 2026#1880.2
Mar 27, 2026#1877.9
Apr 4, 2026#1883.9
Apr 6, 2026#1883.9
Apr 10, 2026#1885.9
Apr 18, 2026#1885.6
Apr 24, 2026#1886.3
May 1, 2026#1786.5
May 8, 2026#1783.5
May 15, 2026#1781.7
May 22, 2026#1781.6
May 29, 2026#1781.5
Jun 5, 2026#1779.6
Jun 12, 2026#1779.8
Jun 19, 2026#1779.8
Jun 26, 2026#1779.5
Jul 3, 2026#1778.5
Jul 10, 2026#1777.6
Jul 17, 2026#1772.1
Jul 24, 2026#1772.1
Jul 31, 2026#1772.1
Aug 7, 2026#1872.2
Aug 14, 2026#1872.2
Aug 21, 2026#1880.1
Aug 28, 2026#1879.8
Sep 4, 2026#1877.8
Sep 11, 2026Not recordedNot recorded76.9
Sep 18, 2026Not recordedNot recorded71.5
Sep 25, 2026Not recordedNot recorded73.5
Oct 2, 2026Not recordedNot recorded73.5
Oct 9, 2026#1882
Oct 9, 2026
Florida category rank#1,927 of 60,336
Award Score82 / 100
Florida category rank and Restaurant Award Score Gold shows recorded category ranks on the left axis, with number one at the top. Mint overlays Restaurant Award Score on an independent right axis from 0 to 100. Lines connect recorded observations; missing values are not estimated. Comparison-field sizes and scoring methodology can change. Use the date slider or the data table below for exact values. Rank Score / 100 #1#734#1,467#2,200 0255075100 Feb 2026May 2026Jul 2026Oct 2026 Florida category rank and Restaurant Award Score Gold shows recorded category ranks on the left axis, with number one at the top. Mint overlays Restaurant Award Score on an independent right axis from 0 to 100. Lines connect recorded observations; missing values are not estimated. Comparison-field sizes and scoring methodology can change. Use the date slider or the data table below for exact values. Rank Score / 100 #1#734#1,467#2,200 0255075100 Feb 2026Jun 2026Oct 2026
View recorded values
DateRankComparison fieldAward Score / 100
Feb 25, 2026#2,15451,18589
Feb 26, 2026#2,15251,20889
Mar 3, 2026#2,13651,45283.5
Mar 6, 2026#2,14151,63380.8
Mar 16, 2026#2,15051,97880.8
Mar 20, 2026#2,15252,11380.2
Mar 27, 2026#2,18452,95277.9
Apr 4, 2026#2,09653,57983.9
Apr 6, 2026#2,10153,71883.9
Apr 10, 2026#2,10853,87885.9
Apr 18, 2026#2,06754,19185.6
Apr 24, 2026#2,07254,09286.3
May 1, 2026#2,03054,07786.5
May 8, 2026#2,04155,28883.5
May 15, 2026#2,04455,29781.7
May 22, 2026#2,04455,40181.6
May 29, 2026#2,03555,63181.5
Jun 5, 2026#2,03655,62679.6
Jun 12, 2026#2,02355,59379.8
Jun 19, 2026#2,01655,55279.8
Jun 26, 2026#2,01655,56579.5
Jul 3, 2026#2,01855,53478.5
Jul 10, 2026#2,02255,50677.6
Jul 17, 2026#2,02755,50872.1
Jul 24, 2026#2,02955,55072.1
Jul 31, 2026#2,00755,56072.1
Aug 7, 2026#2,03359,76272.2
Aug 14, 2026#2,08659,58672.2
Aug 21, 2026#1,89060,34080.1
Aug 28, 2026#1,91560,33479.8
Sep 4, 2026#1,92760,33677.8
Sep 11, 2026Not recordedNot recorded76.9
Sep 18, 2026Not recordedNot recorded71.5
Sep 25, 2026Not recordedNot recorded73.5
Oct 2, 2026Not recordedNot recorded73.5
Oct 9, 2026#1,92760,33682
Oct 9, 2026
United States category rank#9,053 of 857,329
Award Score82 / 100
United States category rank and Restaurant Award Score Gold shows recorded category ranks on the left axis, with number one at the top. Mint overlays Restaurant Award Score on an independent right axis from 0 to 100. Lines connect recorded observations; missing values are not estimated. Comparison-field sizes and scoring methodology can change. Use the date slider or the data table below for exact values. Rank Score / 100 #1#3,801#7,600#11,400 0255075100 Feb 2026May 2026Jul 2026Oct 2026 United States category rank and Restaurant Award Score Gold shows recorded category ranks on the left axis, with number one at the top. Mint overlays Restaurant Award Score on an independent right axis from 0 to 100. Lines connect recorded observations; missing values are not estimated. Comparison-field sizes and scoring methodology can change. Use the date slider or the data table below for exact values. Rank Score / 100 #1#3,801#7,600#11,400 0255075100 Feb 2026Jun 2026Oct 2026
View recorded values
DateRankComparison fieldAward Score / 100
Feb 25, 2026#11,272763,64189
Feb 26, 2026#11,284763,86689
Mar 3, 2026#11,291766,69583.5
Mar 6, 2026#11,322768,29380.8
Mar 16, 2026#11,308772,13580.8
Mar 20, 2026#11,291773,69380.2
Mar 27, 2026#11,360783,06577.9
Apr 4, 2026#10,681790,84583.9
Apr 6, 2026#10,719792,49583.9
Apr 10, 2026#10,762794,47385.9
Apr 18, 2026#10,411798,72685.6
Apr 24, 2026#10,459797,37486.3
May 1, 2026#10,256798,75386.5
May 8, 2026#10,295815,59183.5
May 15, 2026#10,272816,17781.7
May 22, 2026#10,242819,40381.6
May 29, 2026#10,206821,92081.5
Jun 5, 2026#10,225822,10179.6
Jun 12, 2026#10,130821,73879.8
Jun 19, 2026#10,083821,27579.8
Jun 26, 2026#10,087821,38179.5
Jul 3, 2026#10,087821,29678.5
Jul 10, 2026#10,096821,03477.6
Jul 17, 2026#10,122821,17772.1
Jul 24, 2026#10,129821,67672.1
Jul 31, 2026#9,924821,74472.1
Aug 7, 2026#9,973856,16472.2
Aug 14, 2026#10,053850,88872.2
Aug 21, 2026#8,863857,02680.1
Aug 28, 2026#9,011857,25679.8
Sep 4, 2026#9,053857,32977.8
Sep 11, 2026Not recordedNot recorded76.9
Sep 18, 2026Not recordedNot recorded71.5
Sep 25, 2026Not recordedNot recorded73.5
Oct 2, 2026Not recordedNot recorded73.5
Oct 9, 2026#9,053857,32982

Gold traces rank on the left axis (#1 is highest); mint traces Award Score on the right axis (0–100). Lines connect recorded observations. Historical scores reflect the methodology used at each date. Top percentages use the current rank and comparison field, rounded up to one decimal place. Each chart date keeps its recorded field size; coverage and methodology can affect rank. Earned awards retain their original award date and field.

What guests love

The details
guests remember.

For Island Grill, the story in guest feedback is about friendly staff, fast service, fresh food and great value.

2,282customer voices analysedAll-time guest-feedback themes
01

A friendly welcome

The people behind the experience stand out in guest feedback.

02

Service with a good rhythm

Prompt service is one of the positive themes guests mention.

03

Freshness on the plate

Fresh food features among the strengths in the guest record.

04

A sense of good value

Guests highlight value as part of what they appreciate.

Leading positive themes from the all-time public guest-feedback record.

See what shapes this restaurant’s standing.

Claim this venue for free to open every Priority Action in the owner dashboard. Premium adds the complete competitor field.

Premium preview

Competitor List

Reveal every tracked competitor, distance, score, and position change in the local market.

Showing 4 of 100 competitors

Island Grill Your venue
Islamorada, Village of Islands, Florida
You
82.0 Baseline
Midway Cafe & Coffee Bar
7.9 km
79.8 ↓ 2.2
Competitor hidden in this preview
83.5 ↑ 1.5
MEAT Eatery And Taproom
3.9 km
79.4 ↓ 2.6
Nearby venue hidden in this preview
5.1 km
78.7 ↓ 3.3
Owner dashboard preview

Priority Actions

Open the full action plan, including every covered signal and the highest-impact work still pending.

1 covered · 5 pending

Action hidden in this preview Covered
Tighten the website conversion path Needs action
Action detail hidden in this preview Needs action
Protect your positive recommendation rate Needs action
Next step hidden in this preview Needs action
Add an online ordering link Needs action
Owner dashboard

Everything you need to move this venue forward.

One place to publish your recognition and follow the actions, guest feedback, competition, performance, market position, and risk signals connected to your venue.

01 / Award Recognition

Publish your recognition

Your award should travel further than this listing. Give guests a reason to notice you, wherever they find you.

  • Award badges and website embeds
  • Ready-to-share social artwork
From recognition to ready-to-publish.

Layout preview · your actual selected award, placed on a sample website and social post.

02 / Priority Actions

Know exactly what to fix next

Turn the signals already attached to your venue into a focused list of next steps.

  • See the highest-priority gaps first
  • Separate completed work from open actions
From scattered signals to a clear next step.

Illustrative sample, not this venue's data · the owner dashboard shows its own priority list.

03 / Guest Feedback

Hear what guests really say

See the themes guests praise, question, and repeat across public customer voices.

  • Track praise and attention themes
  • Compare sentiment over time
From guest voices to confident decisions.
04 / Local Competition

See where you lead and lag

Benchmark your score, rating, customer-voice volume, and distance against nearby restaurants.

  • Compare the local score distribution
  • Inspect venue-level performance gaps
From guesswork to a clear local benchmark.

Illustrative sample, not this venue's data · nearby venue names are hidden in this preview.

05 / Performance Over Time

Track your score, not just your stars

Follow the movement behind your Restaurant Award Score and its underlying signals.

  • Compare score and component history
  • Spot meaningful changes between updates
From a star rating to the whole story.

Illustrative sample, not this venue's data · the owner dashboard shows its full score history.

06 / Market Rank

Watch your market position move

Follow city, state, national, and category positions from one ranking view.

  • Compare rank across geographic levels
  • See the categories behind each position
From one ranking to your full market position.

Illustrative sample, not this venue's data · the owner dashboard shows its own positions.

07 / Business Risk

Spot risk signals early

Read market pressure, customer-voice momentum, operations, and digital resilience at a glance.

  • Scan the strongest risk drivers
  • See confidence and context together
From early warning to timely action.

Illustrative sample, not a risk assessment of this venue · the owner dashboard shows its own signals.

Smiling restaurant owner using a tablet in a dining room
Your venue. Your view.

Claim Island Grill's profile now.

Bring rankings, awards, Priority Actions, guest feedback, competition, performance, market position, and business-risk signals into one working view.

  • Free to claim
  • Access your venue's award badges
  • No platform integrations required
Claim This Restaurant For Free
For owners

Owner of Island Grill?

Claim this page for free to get the owner dashboard. With Premium, it becomes your restaurant's own profile, with your story, photos, menu and booking links.

What's on this public page vs the owner dashboard?

Public visitors see your headline score, rating, rank and awards. Claiming gives verified owners their restaurant dashboard with the core metrics we already track for the venue, plus a Restaurant Award badge for their website and marketing materials to show off their awards.

How do I claim Island Grill?

Click Claim This Restaurant, verify ownership, and your dashboard access opens right away. Claiming is always free and does not require any integrations.

What do I get after claiming?

You get the owner dashboard for your venue, with the metrics and performance signals we already track, and a Restaurant Award badge for your website. For the first 30 days, the badge shows your award and you can download the marketing materials: a PNG badge, ready-made Instagram posts and a print-ready award certificate. With Premium, they stay available.

Can I download award marketing materials?

Yes. For the first 30 days after claiming, you can download each award your venue earns as a transparent PNG badge, six ready-made Instagram posts and a print-ready certificate for your wall or menu. After that, they are part of Premium.

Do I need to connect any systems?

No. The dashboard is built from data we already collect, so claiming does not require POS, reservation, or customer-feedback platform integrations.

Who should claim the restaurant?

The claim should be completed by the owner, operator, or someone authorized to manage the venue's dashboard access on behalf of the restaurant.

How quickly does the dashboard reflect my restaurant?

Access is available as soon as the claim is verified. The dashboard then reflects the venue data and catalog signals we already maintain for Island Grill.

Can I show the award on our website?

Yes. After claiming, you can add a live Restaurant Award badge to your website with a short embed code, linking to this page. For the first 30 days it shows your award, and with Premium it keeps showing it. Without Premium it then reads “Listed on RestaurantAward.com”, and the code and the link stay the same.

Plan your visit

Visiting Island Grill?

Answers from the public data we track for this venue. Details can change, so check with the restaurant before you go.

Where is Island Grill located?

Island Grill is a seafood restaurant at 85501 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, Village of Islands, Florida 33036. Get directions on Google Maps.

What is the website of Island Grill?

Island Grill runs its own website at keysislandgrill.com. Check it for the latest details straight from the restaurant before your visit in Islamorada, Village of Islands.

What kind of restaurant is Island Grill?

Island Grill is a seafood restaurant in Islamorada, Village of Islands, Florida.

How do guests rate Island Grill?

Island Grill holds a 4.5 average across 3,892 public customer voices. Its Restaurant Award Score of 82.0 adds customer-voice confidence and rating health to that rating.

How does Island Grill rank in Islamorada, Village of Islands?

Island Grill ranks #1 of 8 Restaurants in Islamorada, Village of Islands in the latest weekly Restaurant Award ranking. In Florida, it ranks #1,927 of 60,336. See the full Islamorada, Village of Islands restaurant ranking.

Has Island Grill won any awards?

Yes. Island Grill holds 4 active Restaurant Awards, led by #3 in Islamorada, Village of Islands for Seafood restaurant, out of 8 venues. The other 3 awards are listed on this page. Awards stay active for 60 days from their award date.