Live venue positions in Middletown are temporarily unavailable.

Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown, New York

The ranking podium

Honouring the top spots in Middletown.

A table worth seeking out. Meet the restaurants leading the current rankings in Middletown, New York, and discover what puts each one at the top.

Explore the full ranking
Illustrative image: Exquisitely plated tasting menu course
80.7
#1

Middletown New York

Caputo's Pizza

For a relaxed meal, Caputo's Pizza is one table worth exploring.

View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Intimate chef counter at a fine dining restaurant
75.7
#2

Middletown New York

Little Caesars Pizza

For your next night out, Little Caesars Pizza is a local option.

View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Atmospheric courtyard restaurant in warm evening light
72.1
#3

Middletown New York

Carlos' Pizzeria and Bar

For dinner with friends, Carlos' Pizzeria and Bar is a local option.

View Restaurant

Top Places in Middletown

Illustrative image: Exquisitely plated tasting menu course
#1

Caputo's Pizza

Middletown, New York

1
80.7
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Intimate chef counter at a fine dining restaurant
#2

Little Caesars Pizza

Middletown, New York

1
75.7
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Atmospheric courtyard restaurant in warm evening light
#3

Carlos' Pizzeria and Bar

Middletown, New York

0
72.1
View Restaurant

More Places

Illustrative image: Destination dining room
#4

ONEWAY Cafe and Pizza

Middletown, New York

7
70.2
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Close-up of a bright coastal restaurant dish
#5

Brother Bruno's Pizzeria Middletown

Middletown, New York

1
66.0
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Moody restaurant interior with polished service
#6

Badabing Pizzeria

Middletown, New York

0
64.0
View Restaurant

On the rise in Middletown.

Largest monthly score increases
Illustrative image: Destination dining room
#1

Caputo's Pizza

Middletown, New York

80.7
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Close-up of a bright coastal restaurant dish
#2

Carlos' Pizzeria and Bar

Middletown, New York

72.1
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Moody restaurant interior with polished service
#3

Little Caesars Pizza

Middletown, New York

75.7
View Restaurant
Explore Trending Pizza restaurant