Plotted 3 of 3 venues in Port Jefferson from live position data.

Best American Restaurants in Port Jefferson, New York

The ranking podium

Honouring the top spots in Port Jefferson.

A table worth seeking out. Meet the restaurants leading the current rankings in Port Jefferson, New York, and discover what puts each one at the top.

Explore the full ranking
Illustrative image: Exquisitely plated tasting menu course
80.4
#1

Port Jefferson New York

The Fifth Season Restaurant

For a relaxed meal, The Fifth Season Restaurant is a local option.

View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Intimate chef counter at a fine dining restaurant
74.8
#2

Port Jefferson New York

Local's Cafe

For your next night out, Local's Cafe is a casual choice.

View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Atmospheric courtyard restaurant in warm evening light
72.7
#3

Port Jefferson New York

Nantuckets

For dinner with friends, Nantuckets is one table worth exploring.

View Restaurant

Top Places in Port Jefferson

Illustrative image: Exquisitely plated tasting menu course
#1

The Fifth Season Restaurant

Port Jefferson, New York

12
80.4
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Intimate chef counter at a fine dining restaurant
#2

Local's Cafe

Port Jefferson, New York

7
74.8
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Atmospheric courtyard restaurant in warm evening light
#3

Nantuckets

Port Jefferson, New York

1
72.7
View Restaurant

On the rise in Port Jefferson.

Largest monthly score increases
Illustrative image: Destination dining room
#1

Nantuckets

Port Jefferson, New York

72.7
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Close-up of a bright coastal restaurant dish
#2

The Fifth Season Restaurant

Port Jefferson, New York

80.4
View Restaurant
Illustrative image: Moody restaurant interior with polished service
#3

Local's Cafe

Port Jefferson, New York

74.8
View Restaurant
Explore Trending American restaurant