Live venue positions in Carmel are temporarily unavailable.
Best Sandwich Shop Restaurants in Carmel, Indiana
Honouring the top spots in Carmel.
A table worth seeking out. Meet the restaurants leading the current rankings in Carmel, Indiana, and discover what puts each one at the top.
Explore the full rankingTop Places in Carmel
#1
Penn Station Sandwiches
Carmel, Indiana
1
73.8
#2
Jersey Mike's Subs
Carmel, Indiana
0
71.0
#3
Jersey Mike's Subs
Carmel, Indiana
1
69.8
More Places
On the rise in Carmel.
Largest monthly score increases