Plotted 1 of 1 venues in New Carlisle from live position data.

Best Pizza Restaurants in New Carlisle, Indiana

The ranking podium

Honouring the top spots in New Carlisle.

A table worth seeking out. Meet the restaurants leading the current rankings in New Carlisle, Indiana, and discover what puts each one at the top.

Explore the full ranking
Illustrative image: Exquisitely plated tasting menu course
67.2
#1

New Carlisle Indiana

Black Cat Lanes

For a relaxed meal, Black Cat Lanes is a casual choice.

View Restaurant

Top Places in New Carlisle

Illustrative image: Exquisitely plated tasting menu course
#1

Black Cat Lanes

New Carlisle, Indiana

10
67.2
View Restaurant

On the rise in New Carlisle.

Largest monthly score increases
Illustrative image: Destination dining room
#1

Black Cat Lanes

New Carlisle, Indiana

67.2
View Restaurant
Explore Trending Pizza restaurant