Live venue positions in Indiana are temporarily unavailable.
Best Traditional American Restaurants in Indiana
Honouring the top spots in Indiana.
A table worth seeking out. Meet the restaurants leading the current rankings in Indiana, and discover what puts each one at the top.
Explore the full rankingCities in Indiana
Indianapolis3,037Indianapolis city (balance)3,021Fort Wayne855Evansville531South Bend343Bloomington329Lafayette279Carmel270Fishers267Mishawaka253Elkhart252Terre Haute252Kokomo243Greenwood229Muncie224Noblesville199Gary197Columbus195Anderson186West Lafayette184Hammond176Valparaiso163Jeffersonville156Lawrence149
Top Places in Indiana
#1
Mayberry Cafe
Danville, Indiana
14
81.9
#2
Brick Street Restaurant
North Vernon, Indiana
7
76.6
#3
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Lafayette, Indiana
2
76.3
More Places
#4
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Avon, Indiana
2
75.3
#5
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Bloomington, Indiana
2
74.3
#6
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Evansville, Indiana
1
74.0
#7
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Fort Wayne, Indiana
1
72.3
#8
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Clarksville, Indiana
1
72.1
#9
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Indianapolis, Indiana
2
71.7
#10
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Mishawaka, Indiana
2
71.6
#11
Old Richmond Inn
Richmond, Indiana
5
69.2
#12
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen
Terre Haute, Indiana
1
68.7
#13
Willie and Red’s
Hagerstown, Indiana
22
68.5
#14
John's Famous Stew
Indianapolis, Indiana
1
66.7
#15
2 Chicks Bistro & Bakery
Boonville, Indiana
7
61.3
#16
Smokey Bones Avon
Avon, Indiana
2
18.2
#17
Smokey Bones Fort Wayne
Fort Wayne, Indiana
1
16.0
#18
Smokey Bones Greenwood
Greenwood, Indiana
1
15.8
#19
Smokey Bones Fort Wayne
Fort Wayne, Indiana
1
9.2
On the rise in Indiana.
Largest monthly score increases