Live venue positions in New York are temporarily unavailable.
Best Sandwich Shop Restaurants in New York
More Places
#26
Firehouse Subs North Syracuse
North Syracuse, New York
2
80.3
#27
Beacon Quality Eats
Beacon, New York
1
80.0
#28
Edith’s Sandwich Counter
New York City, New York
0
79.9
#29
Jersey Mike's Subs
Brighton, New York
1
79.9
#30
Benny’s Brown Bag
Peekskill, New York
16
79.8
#31
Defonte's Sandwich Shop
New York City, New York
3
79.7
#32
The Picnic Basket
New York City, New York
1
79.4
#33
Nussy's Cuisine
Monsey, New York
14
79.4
#34
Wise Guys Sammy's
Oneonta, New York
5
79.1
#35
Fair Deli Craft Beer
Lakeland, New York
25
78.9
#36
Little Cabin Sandwich Shop Inc.
Crompond, New York
15
78.7
#37
The Sandwich Spot NY
Valhalla, New York
16
78.4
#38
Jersey Mike's Subs
Batavia, New York
1
78.3
#39
BRENDOS
Williston Park, New York
1
78.3
#40
Anthony's Paninoteca
New York City, New York
0
78.3
#41
My Hero
North Merrick, New York
4
78.2
#42
Jersey Mike's Subs
Greece, New York
4
78.1
#43
PB & J's Lunch Box
Galeville, New York
14
78.0
#44
Blimpie
New Cassel, New York
4
77.5
#45
Jersey Mike's Subs
Riverside, New York
17
77.5
#46
Pat's Submarines
Lackawanna, New York
1
77.3
#47
Firehouse Subs West Henrietta Road
Brighton, New York
2
77.1
#48
Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original
Kenmore, New York
1
77.1
#49
Jreck Subs - Syracuse
Syracuse, New York
1
77.0
#50
Zio's
Buffalo, New York
1
76.9