Live venue positions in New York are temporarily unavailable.
Best Pizza Takeout Restaurants in New York
More Places
#26
Adelina's
Ithaca, New York
1
67.9
#27
Enzo’s Pizza Co.
Johnson City, New York
4
67.2
#28
Uncle Rico's Pizza
Niskayuna, New York
1
65.8
#29
Otis & Lisa's Pizza
Phelps, New York
22
64.6
#30
J and J’s Pizza
Yonkers, New York
2
63.6
#31
Twin Trees
East Syracuse, New York
6
63.6
#32
Gemelli’s Pizzeria
Albany, New York
5
61.9
#33
Maria's Pizza & Bistro
Ronkonkoma, New York
12
61.5
#34
Fullers
Red Creek, New York
3
60.6
#35
Domenico’s Italian eatery
Commack, New York
1
60.5
#36
Dashnaw's Pizzeria
Gouverneur, New York
11
60.4
#37
Hunt Brothers Pizza
Cobleskill, New York
1
60.4
#38
Papa's Pizza Oven Cheektowaga
Cheektowaga, New York
1
59.2
#39
The Nonna's Pizza Gourmet
Eastchester, New York
1
58.9
#40
Pizza Near Me & Italian Takeout
Holbrook, New York
16
56.6
#41
The Buffalo Pizza Beast (late night spot w/ variable hours)
Sloan, New York
21
56.2
#42
That Pizza Joint
Lawrence, New York
1
55.5
#43
Cazanova's Takeout
Buffalo, New York
1
55.3
#44
Nelsons Steak Out
Rensselaer, New York
1
54.7
#45
Broadway Joe’s Pizza & Subs
Schenectady, New York
1
52.3
#46
Mad Pizza
Rochester, New York
1
51.5
#47
Farmingdale Pizza & Pasta
Farmingdale, New York
1
51.4
#48
Papa's Pizza Oven
Lancaster, New York
1
50.8
#49
Mojoes on hudson
Rochester, New York
1
50.5
#50
Little Caesars
Westmere, New York
1
49.8