Live venue positions in Indiana are temporarily unavailable.
Best Italian Restaurants in Indiana
More Places
#101
Good Omen
Zionsville, Indiana
2
72.3
#102
Salvatori's Italian Eatery - Auburn
Auburn, Indiana
6
72.3
#103
DeLullo's Trattoria
Cicero, Indiana
10
72.3
#104
Zianos Italian Eatery
Fort Wayne, Indiana
0
72.1
#105
Paretta's Italian Ristorante
Delphi, Indiana
12
71.9
#106
Johnny Carino's
Greenwood, Indiana
1
71.8
#107
Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery
Granger, Indiana
1
71.7
#108
Cafe Farina Valparaiso
Valparaiso, Indiana
2
71.1
#109
Piada Italian Street Food
Avon, Indiana
1
70.9
#110
Vinatellis Italian Cafe
Markle, Indiana
21
69.9
#111
Angottis Italian Restaurant
Columbus, Indiana
9
69.8
#112
Tuscan Table Ristorante
Greenfield, Indiana
11
69.0
#113
Noble Roman's
Evansville, Indiana
1
68.8
#114
The Spaghetti Junction Restaurant
New Albany, Indiana
1
68.5
#115
Pasto Italiano Restaurant & Bar
Westfield, Indiana
4
68.4
#116
Sandra D's - Italian Garden
Auburn, Indiana
14
68.4
#117
No-ce Italian American Kitchen & Bar
Lawrenceburg, Indiana
1
68.3
#118
Cafe Farina - Michigan City | Italian
Michigan City, Indiana
1
68.0
#119
Nonna's by So Italian
Plainfield, Indiana
3
68.0
#120
Farina's Supper Club
Duneland Beach, Indiana
3
67.7
#121
Awnie’s Italian Cuisine
Martinsville, Indiana
17
67.6
#122
Papa's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine
Brownsburg, Indiana
1
67.4
#123
Papa Vino's Italian Kitchen
Warsaw, Indiana
5
67.3
#124
Gerrie's Italian on 9th Street
Clinton, Indiana
17
67.0
#125
Noble Roman's
Nashville, Indiana
1
66.9